Gems: Editing That Diamond. Rough Draft to Polished Manuscript. Part I
Coming to the end of a rough draft is an exhilarating process. Knowing that you can do it, that you have done it, that you have created a complete novel is something that does not get old, even after completing many novels. No matter how good you get at the writing process, every rough draft will need to be edited. This is one of the fiction writing tips that should never be ignored. If you have mastered the basics such as good grammar, formatting and punctuation, some of the editing steps will go faster than the others.
I liken editing to the process of cleaving, cutting and polishing a diamond. Diamonds take a long time to form, and when they are mined from the earth, they are rough but still beautiful. Each stage in the process is important and essential to getting the most potential out of the tough gem.
Cleaving is the part of editing that can be started right after you have typed ‘the end’. This is where you step back and take a look at the large picture. Macro editing. Do you feel satisfied with your ending at that very moment? Do you have scenes that you will need to insert to make more sense out of your ending? Do you have a character that you need to develop more or one that you need to get rid of all together?
I recommend not actually making any of those changes right away. The diamond cleaver turns the rough gem in his hand and makes observations, then he sets the diamond in a type of cement and walks away from it, letting it cool. I suggest writing your observations and to do list down in notes, backup your draft one final time and then put it away for a minimum of thirty days.
During that waiting period, I take the time to celebrate, but I also start work on a new project. I will work on rough notes or an outline for a new novel or if I do not have an idea for the next book, I will find writing prompts and exercises to do that will usually give me some ideas. A week before I start editing, I will spend some time reading advice from others on the editing process.
When you come back to the manuscript read it all the way through. You will have a fresh perspective on it, and you can start working on those notes that you made earlier with confidence and precision. Tweak your ending, adjust your beginning, remove those characters or scenes that don’t further the plot and add the small foreshadowing details that add depth to the story and give more meaning to the ending. When you are done, put the manuscript away again. For a day, a week or longer if you need to.
For more ideas on macro editing you might find this .pdf file by Robin L. Perini helpful.
And a great book I recommend is:
Self-Editing for Fiction Writers, Second Edition: How to Edit Yourself Into Print
Coming up in Part II of Editing, we will go over the cutting process, where the dust flies and the sparkle begins to come through as clean edges are crafted.
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.





My waiting process is a bit different from yours. I usually edit the story two or three times right after writing, then send it off to my critters. After that, I’ll edit off and on while I’m working on my next project. It’s strange, because I’m never distanced enough from my work to really see it until I’ve finished the next project. So my waiting period can sometimes take years!
[rq=916,0,blog][/rq]Branded: Negotiating Consumerism in Fiction
I think it’s great that there are more ways than one to approach the editing process. I’m too close the story to do anything to it after I have gotten to the end. I need that thirty days away so that I can read critically, as if I was not the author. My first readers won’t see a copy of the manuscript until I have done at least three edits. The macro, the micro and then very detailed line editing.
But I think it’s great that you move on to the next project. That’s probably one of the best things to do. Keep producing.
Thanks for commenting.
[...] This post was Twitted by writerpatty – Real-url.org [...]
Hey, nice post, very well written. You should blog more about this.
[...] part one of my gems series on editing, we discussed macro edit which can be compare to cleaving, the first [...]
[...] presents Gems: Editing That Diamond. Rough Draft to Polished Manuscript. Part I posted at Writer Patty, saying, “Coming to the end of a rough draft is an exhilarating [...]
[...] presents Gems: Editing That Diamond. Rough Draft to Polished Manuscript. Part I posted at Writer Patty, saying, “Coming to the end of a rough draft is an exhilarating [...]
[...] presents Gems: Editing That Diamond. Rough Draft to Polished Manuscript. Part I posted at Writer Patty, saying, “Coming to the end of a rough draft is an exhilarating [...]
Just wanted to say I enjoyed the site. You have really put a lot of time into your content and it is just wonderfull!
[...] part one of my gems series on editing, we discussed macro edit which can be compare to cleaving, the first [...]